Image
  • Home
  • Contact

IS THE DISTRICT GOVERNING BOARD GOING TO HIDE BEHIND ZOOM?

By R. Oliphant
Wednesday, February 12th, 2025

Where is the evidence of Chair McCasland’s “safety concerns” for holding meetings at the Rock House on the Prescott Community College campus? Or elsewhere?

Editor: Robert Oliphant

OPINION: The Chair of the Yavapai Community College District Governing Board, Deb McCasland,  has unilaterally decided that all future board meetings will be held exclusively via Zoom. This apparently includes meetings at the Rock House on the Prescott Community College campus or anywhere else.

Her stated reason? A vague and unsubstantiated email statement received by District Governing Board members sent by the Board Executive Assistant to the President & District Governing Board, which declared in part “that [Chair Deb McCasland] after learning of safety concerns related to our board meetings, . . . has decided that governing board meetings will be held virtually only until further notice.”  This raises an obvious question: What safety concerns?

Despite repeated requests for clarification from some Board members, Ms. McCasland has refused to provide any specific details about what threats, incidents, or conditions necessitate such a drastic shift in how the public Governing Board meetings are held.  If there were genuine concerns about safety—such as specific threats, past disruptions, or law enforcement recommendations—one would expect some form of documentation or at least a public acknowledgment of the issue. But instead, Ms. McCasland  has chosen silence.

The public deserves answers in situations like this for several reasons:

  1. Public safety is an issue concerning the entire community.  If there is a legitimate threat, the community has a right to know. Are there security concerns that affect not just the Governing Board, but also students, faculty, or the broader public? Keeping people in the dark about potential dangers does not enhance safety—it undermines it.

  2. There are potential drawbacks to transitioning to Zoom meetings. For example, it tends to limit a spontaneous response between Governing Board members who are engaged in discussion, reduces opportunities for face-to-face accountability, and allows board members to retreat into a digital echo chamber where tough questions can be most  easily ignored.

  3. Avoiding answering hard questions from Board members is not a valid safety concern. In recent months, public frustration with the Board appears to have grown—particularly over issues like free speech of Board members and taxation. Some members of the Board have been raising these uncomfortable issues.  Could this shift to Zoom be an attempt to electronically silence criticism from certain Governing Board members by easily preventing their questions by muting them with a simple click  rather than a response to an actual threat? Without evidence to the contrary, that suspicion is entirely reasonable.

  4. Other Public Bodies in the County Continue to Meet in Person. City councils, school boards, and other governing entities across Yavapai  County continue to hold public meetings without issue. If they can maintain both safety and accessibility, why can’t the College Board?

  5. No Governing Board members have publicly reported any safety threats. Neither the first nor third District Governing Board member representatives, when interviewed, could recall any safety concerns that arose during recent Governing Board meetings.  Moreover, during the last two January Governing Board hearings, there has been no public disruption of any kind.  In fact, public attendance has been almost nonexistent.

The District Governing Board serves the public, not the other way around. The decision to eliminate in-person meetings should not be accepted without clear, compelling evidence that it is necessary. If safety is truly at risk, the Chair and Board should provide concrete information and work with local authorities to ensure that in-person public meetings can still take place safely and transparently.

Until that happens, this decision looks less like a measure for public safety and more like a move to shield Board members and the College from accountability. That is unacceptable. The community should demand answers—and insist that public meetings remain in a typical public in-person format, not on zoom.

Categories : Editorials/Essays, OPINIONS

Topics

  • Academic awards
  • accreditation
  • ACT
  • ADMINISTRATION
  • Administrative College
  • Admnistrative turnover
  • Advisory Committees
  • Allegations
  • Allied Health Campus
  • Alumni
  • Arizona technical college
  • Art Gallery Event
  • Art programs
  • Asbestos
  • ASU
  • athletic camps & clinics
  • Athletics
  • Attorney fees
  • Audit
  • Aviation program
  • B.A. DEGREES
  • Baseball team
  • Basketball program
  • Basketball program
  • BEAVER CREEK
  • Beer projects
  • Black History Month
  • Bonds
  • Booklets
  • Budget
  • Bus service
  • Butterfly Garden
  • Camp Verde
  • Campaign 2018
  • Career and Technical Education
  • CARES GRANT
  • CARVER MODEL
  • Child Care
  • Chino Valley campus
  • CLOTHING STORE ON PRESCOTT CAMPUS
  • Coconino Community College
  • College for Kids
  • College other than Yavapai
  • Commencement
  • Communication
  • Community College Citizen Advocates
  • COMMUNITY EDUCATION
  • COMMUNITY EVENT NOT PAC
  • Complaints
  • Construction
  • COTTONWOOD COMMUNITY SCHOOL
  • COVID 19
  • Crime
  • CTEC
  • Culinary Arts
  • Cultural Events for the Public
  • CURRICULUM
  • DAKA
  • Detention Academy
  • District Governing Board
  • DK RANCH
  • DOG CERTIFICATES
  • Dropout rate
  • Drug investigation
  • Dual enrollment
  • EARLY COLLEGE ACADEMY
  • Economic Development
  • Economic impact of College
  • Editorials/Essays
  • Educational material references
  • Election 2018
  • Election 2023
  • Embry-Riddle
  • EMPLOYMENT
  • Employment issues
  • Enrollment data
  • Event
  • Executive meetings
  • Faculty
  • Family Enrichment Center
  • FILM
  • Film School
  • Fire Academy
  • Fitness Center
  • Flight school
  • FOOD PANTRY
  • Food service
  • Forum for Public Affairs
  • Foundation
  • Free speech
  • Fundraising events
  • GED
  • Gift of ranch
  • GOVERNING BOARD
  • Graduation
  • Grants
  • Greater Verde Valley Chapter
  • Health Science Building
  • Health Summit
  • History
  • Hotel Restaurant Management
  • Housing
  • Late class offerings
  • Lawsuits
  • LEAD program
  • Learning Centers
  • Lifelong learning
  • Loan repayment
  • MANZANITA
  • Maricopa Community College
  • Maricopa Community Colleges
  • Master documents
  • MASTER PLAN
  • Mayer High School
  • McCASLAND
  • Meeting Notice
  • Memorials
  • MENTAL HEALTH
  • METAVERSITY
  • Mingus Union High School
  • Mountain Institute
  • Movie
  • Multi-use Field
  • Music
  • NARTA
  • Nature trail
  • New Courses
  • Newsletter
  • Non credit courses
  • Northern Arizona University
  • Nursing
  • OER
  • OLLI (Osher Lifelong Learning)
  • On line classes and accreditation
  • Open Meeting Law
  • OPINIONS
  • Paramedic
  • Performing Arts Center
  • Policy Governance Indoctrination
  • Policy Manual
  • Politics
  • Polling data
  • Population
  • POVERTY
  • Prescott Campus
  • PRESCOTT PINES CAMP
  • Prescott Valley Campus
  • PRINTER 3D
  • Prison program
  • Property purchase
  • Rad Tech
  • Rankings
  • Regional Economic Development Ctr
  • Residence halls
  • RV PARK ON VERDE CAMPUS
  • Salaries
  • Scholarships
  • Search Committee
  • Secret meetings
  • Sedona Arts Center
  • Sedona Campus
  • Sedona land settlement
  • Small Business Development
  • Small Business Development Center
  • Soccer team
  • Softball team
  • SOFTWARE UPGRADE
  • Solar projects
  • Southwest Wine Center
  • Sports in General
  • STAFF
  • Strategic Plan
  • Student achievements
  • Student Organizations
  • SUMMER CLASSES
  • Survey results
  • Surveys
  • Taxes
  • Ten year plan
  • Ten Year Plan Construction
  • Tennis Court
  • TINY HOME PROJECT
  • Trail
  • Transportation
  • Truth in advertising
  • Tuition
  • UNDERSERVED
  • Underserving the Verde Valley
  • Univ of Arizona
  • University of Arizona
  • VACTE
  • Verde Campus
  • Verde campus events
  • Verde Tech High School
  • Verde Valley Forum for Public Affairs
  • Veterans Administration
  • Video
  • Videotape
  • Virtual Reality
  • Viticulture
  • Vocational Education
  • Vocational training
  • Volleyball team
  • WAKE UP VERDE VALLEY BOOK ED 1
  • WAKE UP VERDE VALLEY FIRST EDITION
  • Waste
  • Web sites
  • Weight room
  • Wills salary
  • Wine Center
  • WORKFORCE PROJECT
  • World War I symposium
  • Yavapai Community College
  • Yavapai-Apache Nation