Image
  • Home
  • Contact

FIVE-YEAR MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR LAWSUIT AGAINST THE COMMUNITY COLLEGE HAS ELEVEN PARTIES; 9 OF WHOM ARE DEFENDANTS PLUS U.S. GOVERNMENT

By R. Oliphant
Sunday, June 24th, 2018

List of attorneys representing various parties as far back as 2015 follows below; who is paying for all this legal representation?

The five-year multi-million dollar lawsuit between the former director of aviation programs at Yavapai College, Dan Hamilton, and the College is headed for a jury trial based on the most recent ruling by Federal District Judge Murray Snow.  It has dragged on for five years. There appear to be eleven parties including the plaintiff, nine defendants, and the United States Government. (Note that some named defendants are sued in different capacities, thus the extended list of parties.)

One of the questions about the lawsuit is who is paying for the several defense attorneys involved in the action? And how much has been paid?  And how much is owing?  No one on the College Governing Board has publicly asked for that information and the College has not provided the information to the public.

If the lawsuit is not settled, the jury will be asked to decide whether the College took sufficient steps to inform the VA about how the College was  calculating the 85/15 rule. Hamilton alleges that Yavapai College and its airplane program partner, NorthAire Aviation, violated the Veteran’s Administration funding rule that limits VA beneficiary enrollment to 85% in any program.  (In other words, the program must have at least 15% of its enrollees as civilians.)

In his most recent rulings, Federal District Court Judge Murray Snow wrote that there are “competing issues of material fact as to whether the VA explicitly authorized” Yavapai College to use the calculation it did to arrive at an 85/15 ratio.  The conflict in testimony is between the College’s Certifying Official, Ms. Aldrich, and the VA representative, Ms. Swafford.

The attorneys listed by the United States District Court, D. Arizona, listed the following defendants and their attorneys as of April 1, 2015.

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case (2015 list)

Daniel Hamilton, Plaintiff, represented by Krista Michelle Carman , Warnock MacKinlay & Carman PLLC &Richard James Harris , Richard J Harris & Associates PC.

Yavapai Community College District, Defendant, represented by Elizabeth Ann Gilbert , Jones Skelton & Hochuli PLC.

Yavapai Community College District, Defendant, represented by Georgia A Staton , Jones Skelton & Hochuli PLC.

Yavapai Community College District, Defendant, represented by Steven Douglas Leach , Jones Skelton & Hochuli PLC.

Guidance Academy LLC, Defendant, represented by Dan W Goldfine , Snell & Wilmer LLP, Donald Charles Zavala, Jr. , Boyle Pecharich Cline Whittington, James Michael Gottry , Snell & Wilmer LLP & Joshua Grabel , Snell & Wilmer LLP.

John L Stonecipher, Defendant, represented by Dan W Goldfine , Snell & Wilmer LLP, Donald Charles Zavala, Jr. , Boyle Pecharich Cline Whittington, James Michael Gottry , Snell & Wilmer LLP & Joshua Grabel , Snell & Wilmer LLP.

Amanda Alsobrook, Defendant, represented by Dan W Goldfine , Snell & Wilmer LLP, Donald Charles Zavala, Jr. , Boyle Pecharich Cline Whittington, James Michael Gottry , Snell & Wilmer LLP & Joshua Grabel , Snell & Wilmer LLP.

John Morgan, Defendant, represented by Donald Peder Johnsen , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Georgia A Staton , Jones Skelton & Hochuli PLC & Steven Douglas Leach , Jones Skelton & Hochuli PLC.

John Morgan, named as: husband on second amended complaint, Defendant, represented by Jodi Renee Bohr , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

April Morgan, Defendant, represented by Donald Peder Johnsen , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Georgia A Staton , Jones Skelton & Hochuli PLC, Steven Douglas Leach , Jones Skelton & Hochuli PLC & Jodi Renee Bohr , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

United States of America, Movant, represented by Lon R Leavitt , US Attorneys Office & Todd Frederick Lang , US Attorneys Office.


 

Categories : Lawsuits

Topics

  • Academic awards
  • accreditation
  • ACT
  • ADMINISTRATION
  • Administrative College
  • Admnistrative turnover
  • Advisory Committees
  • Allegations
  • Allied Health Campus
  • Alumni
  • Arizona technical college
  • Art Gallery Event
  • Art programs
  • Asbestos
  • ASU
  • athletic camps & clinics
  • Athletics
  • Attorney fees
  • Audit
  • Aviation program
  • B.A. DEGREES
  • Baseball team
  • Basketball program
  • Basketball program
  • BEAVER CREEK
  • Beer projects
  • Black History Month
  • Bonds
  • Booklets
  • Budget
  • Bus service
  • Butterfly Garden
  • Camp Verde
  • Campaign 2018
  • Career and Technical Education
  • CARES GRANT
  • CARVER MODEL
  • Child Care
  • Chino Valley campus
  • CLOTHING STORE ON PRESCOTT CAMPUS
  • Coconino Community College
  • College for Kids
  • College other than Yavapai
  • Commencement
  • Communication
  • Community College Citizen Advocates
  • COMMUNITY EDUCATION
  • COMMUNITY EVENT NOT PAC
  • Complaints
  • Construction
  • COTTONWOOD COMMUNITY SCHOOL
  • COVID 19
  • Crime
  • CTEC
  • Culinary Arts
  • Cultural Events for the Public
  • CURRICULUM
  • DAKA
  • Detention Academy
  • District Governing Board
  • DK RANCH
  • DOG CERTIFICATES
  • Dropout rate
  • Drug investigation
  • Dual enrollment
  • EARLY COLLEGE ACADEMY
  • Economic Development
  • Economic impact of College
  • Editorials/Essays
  • Educational material references
  • Election 2018
  • Election 2023
  • Embry-Riddle
  • EMPLOYMENT
  • Employment issues
  • Enrollment data
  • Event
  • Executive meetings
  • Faculty
  • Family Enrichment Center
  • FILM
  • Film School
  • Fire Academy
  • Fitness Center
  • Flight school
  • FOOD PANTRY
  • Food service
  • Forum for Public Affairs
  • Foundation
  • Free speech
  • Fundraising events
  • GED
  • Gift of ranch
  • GOVERNING BOARD
  • Graduation
  • Grants
  • Greater Verde Valley Chapter
  • Health Science Building
  • Health Summit
  • History
  • Hotel Restaurant Management
  • Housing
  • Late class offerings
  • Lawsuits
  • LEAD program
  • Learning Centers
  • Lifelong learning
  • Loan repayment
  • MANZANITA
  • Maricopa Community College
  • Maricopa Community Colleges
  • Master documents
  • MASTER PLAN
  • Mayer High School
  • McCASLAND
  • Meeting Notice
  • Memorials
  • MENTAL HEALTH
  • METAVERSITY
  • Mingus Union High School
  • Mountain Institute
  • Movie
  • Multi-use Field
  • Music
  • NARTA
  • Nature trail
  • New Courses
  • Newsletter
  • Non credit courses
  • Northern Arizona University
  • Nursing
  • OER
  • OLLI (Osher Lifelong Learning)
  • On line classes and accreditation
  • Open Meeting Law
  • OPINIONS
  • Paramedic
  • Performing Arts Center
  • Policy Governance Indoctrination
  • Policy Manual
  • Politics
  • Polling data
  • Population
  • POVERTY
  • Prescott Campus
  • PRESCOTT PINES CAMP
  • Prescott Valley Campus
  • PRINTER 3D
  • Prison program
  • Property purchase
  • Rad Tech
  • Rankings
  • Regional Economic Development Ctr
  • Residence halls
  • RV PARK ON VERDE CAMPUS
  • Salaries
  • Scholarships
  • Search Committee
  • Secret meetings
  • Sedona Arts Center
  • Sedona Campus
  • Sedona land settlement
  • Small Business Development
  • Small Business Development Center
  • Soccer team
  • Softball team
  • SOFTWARE UPGRADE
  • Solar projects
  • Southwest Wine Center
  • Sports in General
  • STAFF
  • Strategic Plan
  • Student achievements
  • Student Organizations
  • SUMMER CLASSES
  • Survey results
  • Surveys
  • Taxes
  • Ten year plan
  • Ten Year Plan Construction
  • Tennis Court
  • TINY HOME PROJECT
  • Trail
  • Transportation
  • Truth in advertising
  • Tuition
  • UNDERSERVED
  • Underserving the Verde Valley
  • Univ of Arizona
  • University of Arizona
  • VACTE
  • Verde Campus
  • Verde campus events
  • Verde Tech High School
  • Verde Valley Forum for Public Affairs
  • Veterans Administration
  • Video
  • Videotape
  • Virtual Reality
  • Viticulture
  • Vocational Education
  • Vocational training
  • Volleyball team
  • WAKE UP VERDE VALLEY BOOK ED 1
  • WAKE UP VERDE VALLEY FIRST EDITION
  • Waste
  • Web sites
  • Weight room
  • Wills salary
  • Wine Center
  • WORKFORCE PROJECT
  • World War I symposium
  • Yavapai Community College
  • Yavapai-Apache Nation