Uncertainties Surrounding the Project: The Tiny Home Project, which involves students constructing miniscule houses intended for rent by staff, faculty, and students, still has several unresolved issues. Key questions include the final location of these homes and the total number that the College plans to eventually construct. While it is believed there will be six or seven homes located at the Chino Valley Center, it is not all that clear based on the information provided the District Governing Board from October 2022 to November 2023.
Historical Records of the Project:
October 2022 – College Shares Ideas with Governing Board: In October 2022, Yavapai Community College’s administration first introduced the concept of students building tiny homes for the college community. During a discussion, Third District Representative Paul Chevalier inquired whether the construction would occur on both sides of the mountain, to which the administration affirmed.
May 2023 – Interview with Phoenix Channel Three Television: Dr. Clint Ewell, in a May 2023 interview with Phoenix’s Channel Three news, shifted the focus to primarily using these small houses for students. He highlighted a key issue: “Our recruiting pools have been getting smaller, which we believe is due to the high cost of living in Yavapai County, currently about 20% above the national average.” During this segment, Dr. Ewell expressed hope that a 200-square-foot house, built by students, would attract more enrollees. He noted, “Many students have told us they accepted our program but later withdrew due to the lack of affordable housing.”
According to the Channel Three report, the initial goal is to have three tiny homes available for rent by students at the Chino Valley Center by Spring 2024. However, this objective became uncertain following a housing report presented at the November 2023 Governing Board meeting.
November 2023 – Governing Board Meeting: At the District Governing Board meeting in November 2023, Dr. Ewell informed the Trustees that construction of tiny houses was underway by students at both the Verde Campus and the Career and Technical Education Center (CTEC) at the Prescott Airport. He estimated, “By the end of the school year, we should have six or seven homes ready. We plan to place them either at the Chino campus or the Verde campus to provide housing for students and staff. These homes, ranging from 240 to 300 square feet, are not only compact but also well-constructed and thoughtfully designed.”
As of today, the tiny homes constructed at the Verde Campus remain in the parking lot outside the small Career and Technical Education facility, where they have been for several months. There also appears no movement to prepare an infrastructure on the Verde Campus on which they can be located.
The Yavapai Community College Administration has informed the District Governing Board that it is considering purchasing an additional 3D concrete housing printer, estimated to cost $550,000. (Refer to the video clip below for more details.) If approved, this acquisition would increase the total expenditure on 3D printers by the Community College to approximately one million dollars since 2020.
Recall that on January 27, 2020, the District Governing Board did not oppose a proposal from the College executives to spend nearly half a million dollars on two 3D concrete printers. The information provided to the Board at that time indicated that these printers could construct the foundation, interior, and exterior walls of a medium-sized home within 3-5 days.
However, these two printers proved unsuitable for the intended purpose, as acknowledged by the College executives. Consequently, they were discarded, and the College staff initiated a challenging, time-consuming program to develop and construct the College’s own 3D printers. To the astonishment of careful observers of the College budget, the College Administrators are contemplating asking the Board to approve the purchase of a new 3D printer, despite the substantial previous investment and obvious failures.
It should also be a concern of County taxpayers that so far only a few students have enrolled in courses related to the 3D printing project. Moreover, the initial plan to recoup some of the considerable expenditure by developing and patenting a special cement mixture failed to materialize.
The District Governing Board, responsible for ensuring the prudent use of taxpayer money, seems unable to grasp the problematic history of this project or justify the expenditure of hundreds of thousands of dollars to train so few students. One wonders what it will take to wake this sleepy board up to its statutory responsibility in matters like this.
Throughout Dr. Mercado’s journey as a non-traditional student, she has had women in the roles of professors and administrative assistants walk alongside and stand with her through every challenge, offering encouragement so that she could complete her educational goals for quality of life. After spending 28 years in the community college environment, Dr. Mercado believes that education is the empowerment and equalizer of overcoming societal inequalities. Helping students achieve their educational goals and fostering leadership qualities and abilities in women are paramount to her role and responsibilities in higher education. She is passionate about seeing women become all they desire to be by investing time with them, hearing their concerns, understanding their visions and goals, and providing resources so that they may achieve all they are meant to achieve in fulfilling their destiny. For Dr. Mercado, there is no greater joy.
Recall that back on January 27, 2020, the District Governing Board showed no opposition to a proposal made by the College executives to spend almost a half million dollars to purchase two 3D concrete printers. The information given to the Board at the time suggested that the printers could complete the foundation, interior, and exterior walls for a medium-sized home in 3-5 days.
After roofing, electrical, plumbing, and other services were installed, it was thought that these 3D printed homes could help alleviate Yavapai College’s attainable housing shortage by providing temporary housing for staff, faculty, or students. This innovative approach seemed like a promising solution to a pressing problem.
However, after Governing Board approval and the investment of the half million dollars, the College eventually had to scrap the purchased 3D printers and construct their own, using its own staff and materials. The purchased printers were not fit for the purpose intended by the College.
The next bit of information surfaced in December 2020, when a brief announcement in the College’s Facilities Management Newsletter revealed ongoing work to equip the 3D housing sites (possibly three of them) at the Chino Valley Center with essential utilities. The announcement stated, “Facilities Management is aiding the 3D house printing project by installing electrical, data, and water services for up to three houses at the construction site. Moreover, the Chino Ag Center will serve as a platform to display the program’s capabilities.”
However, since December 2020, Yavapai Community College’s disclosure about the status of the 3D homes has been at best sparse. That changed slightly when, during a brief moment at the November 26, 2023, Governing Board meeting, some light was shed on this project.
The scrap of information came in response to a succinct question from Chair Deb McCasland about the status of those homes. “What is the plan for the houses built on the Chino Valley Campus?” she asked. In response, Community College Vice President of Finance and Administrative Services, Clint Ewell, surprised some listeners by stating: “Those are actually not certified for occupancy. So those will just be basically demonstration homes.”
Recall, as noted earlier, that since 2020 many, if not most, had assumed that the 3D cement homes being constructed would, when completed, provide temporary housing for College faculty, staff, or students. But as clarified in Ms. McCasland’s query, this will not be the case. They cannot be occupied!
It is worth noting that the total amount, running into hundreds of thousands of dollars, invested by the College in this endeavor remains hidden from the public. The District Governing Board, charged with the dual responsibility of judiciously using taxpayer funds and keeping the community informed about spending, seems to have missed the mark over the past three years in ensuring transparency and accountability for this project.
Tuition increases at Yavapai Community College are annually approved by the District Governing Board with little significant questioning or commentary. The meeting on November 26, concerning the requested tuition increase for the 2024-2025 academic year, was no exception.
The College, evidently in need of more funds as it plans to spend millions expanding the Prescott Campus and its three west county centers, proposed major across-the-board tuition hikes. It also proposed slashing or eliminating some discounts now deemed too costly to maintain.
The increases vary: General Education courses, labeled as “tier one” in the three-tier rate system, will see a 5% hike. “Lab courses” in tier two will experience a 6% increase. The Career and Technical Education courses, along with Allied Health offerings, are set for a 7% rise.
The basic nursing courses, typically filled to capacity, will see an increase of $25 per course. Online upper-division classes will be raised by $38 per credit, exceeding the College’s initial tuition projections. The upper-division nursing program is set to begin in fall 2024.
High school students enrolled in concurrent high school and Community College courses will see their existing 50% discount reduced to 25%. The program that allowed students taking 12 full-time classes in a semester to take additional classes for free was discontinued due to perceived overuse.
It took the Governing Board only about eight minutes to approve the College’s proposal. None of the Board members, except Mr. Sigafoos, posed any inquiries or made notable comments during the vote to approve the increases.